.png)
Understanding the Rise of Transgender Shooters - Will society listen to this transman's warning?
- Transman Scott Newgent
- Sep 15
- 10 min read
What is my concern?
Brace yourself, because what I’m about to reveal will absolutely shock you. It’s going to turn everything you thought you knew about transgender shooters upside down and challenge your perceptions in ways that you never saw coming. Get ready for a whole new perspective that will make you rethink everything.
I am a 52-year-old transgender man. However, my political beliefs have always leaned to the right, even as a lesbian who medically transitioned to a transman. This unique perspective has allowed me to understand both sides of the political spectrum, a viewpoint that many may not possess.
Even with evidence and insight, I have struggled to alert the media about the impending violent threats and potential carnage. After the assassination of Charlie Kirk, will the media finally be ready to hear my concerns, or will they go unheard yet again? If so, how many more lives will be lost?
I entered the political arena over seven years ago, where I helped draft the first bill in a state house to ban childhood medical transition. Although our initial attempt in North Dakota in 2019 was unsuccessful, the bill has since been adopted, and now 27 states have enacted laws banning childhood medical transition. Unfortunately, few of these laws are being enforced, but progress is being made.
In 2022, I was featured as the hero in Matt Walsh's documentary "What is a Woman?" In that film, I stood up against the medical transition of children, becoming the first within the LGBTQ+ community to raise concerns and question the impact of these practices on kids, while firmly opposing them as a trans man
I embarked on my medical transition at 42, marking the beginning of a transformative journey that has spanned over a decade. In reflecting on my experiences, I've gained insights that often go overlooked but are crucial for the well-being of our society.
My primary concern has always been for the safety of children—this concern has not waned. However, I've also observed a troubling trend that has emerged, one that I’ve been discussing with my journalist friends, often to mixed responses. Deep down, I hoped to be wrong, but I’ve sensed a troubling rise in violence involving transgender individuals and other acts that cannot be ignored.
If this information is something you believe society needs to know about?
We are standing at the precipice of a significant moment in history, and it’s imperative that we heed this warning with both clarity and compassion. To protect our communities, we must prioritize understanding over sensationalism. It’s time to come together, recognize these patterns, and take action that cultivates safety and harmony rather than chasing clicks or fame. Let’s be the voice of reason and actively work toward a future where everyone can thrive.
Charlie Kirk, a conservative influencer, was recently shot and killed during a rally at Utah Valley University. The suspect, 22-year-old Robinson, has been charged with his murder. According to Utah Governor Spencer Cox, Robinson was involved in a tumultuous romantic relationship with his transgender roommate, who is cooperating with law enforcement. Robinson faces severe charges, including aggravated murder, and is being held without bail. This connection to transgender issues has shocked society, but I, on the other hand, have been anticipating such an incident, and it has finally occurred.
In recent years, we have seen a rise in violence associated with transgender ideology, which raises the question: why? I believe I may have some insights. Before I elaborate, here is a list of instances of transgender ideology-related violence from around the world. Unfortunately, I do not have the space to list them all, but you will get the idea as you read through the top ten.
Robert "Robin" Westman, the shooter, died from a self-inflicted gunshot wound after opening fire outside Annunciation Catholic Church and school. He killed two children, ages eight and ten, and injured 17 others, including 14 children. In a manifesto, Westman, who identified as transgender, expressed regret, saying, "I am tired of being trans; I wish I never brainwashed myself."
A transgender individual has been handed a 22-year prison sentence for the shocking stabbing murder of Portland taxi driver Moses J. Lopez, 30. During the sentencing, the perpetrator showed a chilling lack of remorse, even laughing in the face of Lopez's grieving family. Convicted of first-degree manslaughter and unlawful use of a weapon, they struck a deal with Judge Heidi Moawad that led to the dismissal of an additional case involving threats against another victim. Just before the murder, this individual had been released on bail, making their way from Coos Bay, Oregon, to commit this horrific act.
Transgender activist Sarah Jane Baker, who spent 30 years in prison for attempted murder, took the stage at a Trans+ Pride event in London. During her fiery speech, she challenged the crowd to take a stand against critics of transgender rights. In a provocative remark, she incited violence against her opponents, declaring, "If you see a TERF, punch them in the f****** face."
In March 2023, Audrey "Aiden" Hale unleashed chaos at the Covenant School in Nashville, Tennessee, where she ruthlessly opened fire, killing three students and three staff members before being taken down by police. In the aftermath, her writings surfaced, exposing her inner turmoil over her gender identity. She made disturbing references to an "imaginary penis" and a dark yearning to consult a "trans doctor." Hale's anger was palpable as she grappled with her female gender role, fueled by a fierce desire for a radical transformation.
On April 1, 2023, a Trans Day of Visibility rally in Vancouver erupted into chaos as hundreds of supporters clashed with dissenters, prominently featuring Billboard Chris, an outspoken critic of child transitioning. In the midst of his heated demonstration, Billboard Chris was brutally attacked by a Trans activist, an act of violence witnessed by police officers present at the scene. Following the assault, Billboard Chris posted a shocking video revealing his injuries, revealing the extent of the violence he suffered. Despite the clear aggression, police opted not to press charges against the assailant. The footage quickly went viral, prompting the Vancouver Police Department to launch an investigation into the incident.
A transwoman, MG, faces charges of common assault following a violent altercation at the "Let Women Speak" event on March 25, 2025, where Posie Parker was speaking. During a heated protest against Parker, MG's group violently pushed over a fence and charged towards Parker's supporters. When one supporter attempted to intervene, MG lost control and unleashed a furious attack, brutally striking her in the head three times. Believing the supporter had harmed a fellow protester, MG reacted with overwhelming aggression.
On November 19, 2022, a horrific shooting erupted at Club Q, an LGBTQ nightclub in Colorado Springs, when Anderson Lee Aldrich unleashed a barrage of gunfire, leaving five people dead and injuring 40 others in a chaotic scene of terror. Aldrich, who identifies as nonbinary and uses they/them pronouns, was violently subdued by courageous patrons who fought back against the attack. In June 2023, Aldrich was sentenced to life in prison for their brutal actions.
On May 7, 2019, a brutal shooting erupted at the STEM School in Highlands Ranch, Colorado, leaving one person dead and eight others wounded. Eighteen-year-old Kendrick Castillo lost his life while valiantly confronting one of the assailants. Alec McKinney, a trans-identified teen, was sentenced to life in prison plus 38 years for meticulously plotting the attack as an act of vengeance for bullying. Co-defendant Devon Erickson was handed a life sentence in September 2021. The shooters had consumed cocaine and procured firearms that were stolen from Erickson's parents before unleashing chaos on that tragic day.
On September 20, 2018, Snochia Moseley, a 26-year-old transgender man, unleashed a horrifying attack at a Rite Aid warehouse in Aberdeen, Maryland, fatally gunning down three individuals and injuring three more. Friends revealed that Moseley had been grappling with intense emotions and contemplating hormone treatment since December 2016. Witnesses noted that he arrived at work that day filled with rage, eager for confrontation, setting the stage for chaos and tragedy.
Evie Amati, 24, attacked customers with an axe at a 7-Eleven in Emore on January 7, 2017, injuring Ben Rimmer and Sharon Hacker. A third man, Shane Redwood, was unharmed by using his backpack as a shield. Prosecutors said Amati acted out of rage after being rejected by a woman on Tinder due to her being transgender. In August 2018, she was convicted of wounding Rimmer, inflicting grievous bodily harm on Hacker with intent to murder, and attempting to wound Redwood. In January, Amati was sentenced to nine years in prison, with a non-parole period of four and a half years.
In 2015, after an evening spent with my wife watching Jazz Jennings, the transgender girl whose journey we had followed from childhood, I made a lighthearted comment: "Maybe I was born in the wrong body." To my surprise, my future wife seized upon the idea with enthusiasm, suggesting that it could indeed be true. She often joked that I was a man trapped in a woman’s body, and she insisted that she wasn't a lesbian. I was simply an anomaly that she loved by chance.
Was she right, I wondered? Maybe, just maybe, my struggle to fit in was due to the fact that I was born in the wrong body. One week later, during a visit with a trans woman therapist, she asked, “How long have you been dressing like a man?” Looking back, I find that question odd; after all, I was in a woman’s business suit, wearing earrings and makeup. However, at that vulnerable moment, I wasn’t shocked—I was embarrassed that I might have missed signs that others had noticed since my birth, signs that indicated I was walking around in the wrong body.
Fast forward to an appointment three days later with an OB/GYN who questioned whether I might be intersex. He was almost certain without needing any expensive tests, and I began to feel increasingly convinced that this was the answer to my sense of unease. I started to see myself as a victim in need of correction.
During my visit to the doctor, where I was prescribed synthetic testosterone on the first visit, I encountered a shocking reality about the potential emotional disturbances that can occur during the transition process—something that is rarely discussed. The conversation unfolded like this.
"Kellie, we are unsure about the exact amount of testosterone to prescribe. Medical transition is highly experimental. However, we do know that you have a typical level of estrogen present for an adult female. To transition your body to function primarily on testosterone, we can’t simply provide a small dose or even the amount a typical male would receive. We need to deliver a significant shock to your system so it recognizes that it should operate on testosterone."
As I reflect on the past, I can hardly believe that I, a 42-year-old successful woman, did not shy away from the conversation I was overhearing. When you feel like you don't belong and a person of prominence, like a doctor, tells you there is a cure, you become euphoric at the prospect of finally fitting in.
Currently, there are very few regulations surrounding medical transition. In fact, it seems that the more unstable a person is, the quicker they are pushed through the process. The mental health community often believes that medical transition will resolve mental health issues. Still, the truth is, if someone is dealing with mental illness at the time of their transition, things may actually worsen. The evidence speaks for itself.
When we delve into the realm of synthetic hormones, we uncover a shocking reality that raises profound concerns. But the situation spirals from there, plunging deeper into darkness. Picture this: a staggering number of individuals who embark on medical transitions are often battling severe mental health struggles. We’re talking about dangerous personality disorders—such as malignant narcissism—that can twist their perceptions of reality. Layer this turmoil with delusional disorders and alarming sexual fetishes, like autogynephilia, where some men derive a distorted sense of arousal from being viewed as sexual objects.
Imagine for a moment a man who suffers from a sexual fetish called autogynephilia, as well as personality disorders and delusions. Society encourages him to see himself as a victim while he struggles with his body. He supplies himself with a healthy level of testosterone, despite having massive amounts of estrogen introduced into his system, which can be, in some cases, three times the amount a normal biological female produces. If you are a woman, you understand the effects of hormonal imbalances. Are you now surprised by the increase in violence?
Now, consider the societal implications of this chaos. The overwhelming validation of victimhood and the relentless pressure on society to comply with these complex issues culminate in a crisis that is both significant and alarming. We find ourselves teetering on the edge of a monumental problem, one that demands urgent attention and reckoning. The stakes have never been higher.
Listen, it's not easy to say this as a transman, but someone has to call out the elephant in the room. The reality is we have a ticking time bomb, and I believe things will only get worse if we don’t stop trying to fight against each other to prove a point. Instead, we need to focus on finding a solution.
So, what is that solution?
In the complex landscape of gender identity, we need leaders who acknowledge the nuanced realities, those who can speak from the grey area where calm and truth reside. It's crucial to recognize that while some individuals do medically transition and find peace—like Buck Angel, for instance—this is not a universal experience. We must champion the rights of those who choose this path, affording them the dignity and respect they deserve.
At the same time, it’s essential to face difficult conversations without shying away out of fear of offending. We must avoid dismissing the entire spectrum of trans experiences by labelling them as problematic or dangerous.
Envision a scenario where anyone seeking medical transition must go through a thorough 24-month evaluation process that assesses their mental and emotional readiness. This rigorous journey can be incredibly taxing on an individual's physical, emotional, and spiritual health. By embracing openness and understanding, we can foster a more compassionate dialogue about these vital issues, ultimately leading to greater acceptance and support for all parties involved.
Cosmetic procedures, including medical transition, should be a right for everyone. However, we must prioritize the safety of society as a whole. The best way to protect everyone involved is through regulations that should not be viewed as transphobic, but rather as a compassionate approach for all, including society at large.
If not, then baby, the violence has just begun and one big, "I told you so,' is inevitable.
-Scott Newgent
Donate if you believe this type of information is needed.
